The Fall Favorites Collection: 5 Coffees and Teas That Define Autumn Mornings
There's a specific feeling to fall mornings that no other season matches.
The light shifts. Mornings turn crisp. Something in us wants coffee that tastes like the season - not the bright, acidic iced coffee of July, but something deeper, warmer, more comforting. Something that pairs with a slice of pumpkin bread. Something that makes a Saturday morning feel like a quiet celebration.
That's exactly what we built the Fall Favorites Collection for.
Five curated coffees and teas, each designed to bring a different piece of autumn into your mornings - from pumpkin pie in your coffee cup to toasted pecan in your espresso, to cozy spiced teas for the slower afternoons.
And right now, select fall coffees are 10% off, with free shipping on orders over $35. Here's the complete guide to what's in the collection and which one is right for you.
Shop the Fall Favorites Collection →
Why This Collection Exists
Fall deserves its own coffee lineup. Here's why:
🍂 Palates genuinely shift with the season Bright, acidic coffees that tasted perfect over ice in July start to feel sharp on a cool October morning. Deeper, richer flavors feel more aligned with autumn.
🌾 The food pairing changes Fall foods lean toward spiced, roasted, buttery flavors. Pumpkin bread, apple pie, maple everything. Coffee has to earn its place next to those foods.
🕯️ The ritual slows down Summer coffee is often on-the-go. Fall coffee invites sitting still with a mug. The lineup needs to reward that slower pace.
🥛 Milk drinks come back Lattes, cappuccinos, cortados. Fall is when milk drinks return to morning routines. The coffee has to work beautifully with milk.
🫖 Tea has its moment too Fall isn't just coffee season. Spiced teas, fruit teas, rooibos - they all come alive this time of year.
Our Fall Favorites Collection answers all of this. Here's what's in it:
🎃 Pumpkin Pie Coffee - $32.04 (10% off, reg. $35.60)
The direct one. Our Pumpkin Pie Coffee has pumpkin pie spice roasted right into the specialty beans - real cinnamon, nutmeg, clove, and ginger warming the coffee itself.
What it tastes like:
- Warm pumpkin pie spice
- Smooth, well-balanced body
- Natural sweetness without added sugar
- Cozy, dessert-adjacent character
Who it's for: ✅ PSL lovers who want the flavor without a 50g sugar bomb ✅ Anyone who wants a seasonal coffee without complicated recipes ✅ People who love flavored coffees but hate artificial flavoring
How to brew it:
- Fast morning: Drip coffee maker with milk and a touch of maple
- Weekend indulgence: Make it the base for a homemade PSL (see our full PSL recipe)
- Daily routine: French Press with cream for a rich, satisfying cup
The 90-second PSL hack: Brew it strong, steam some milk with a splash of maple, pour together. Done.
🔥 Fireside Glow Coffee - $32.04 (10% off, reg. $35.60)
The sophisticated one. Fireside Glow brings honey and toasty pecan confection notes - a slightly more grown-up take on fall flavors. If Pumpkin Pie Coffee is the warm hug, Fireside Glow is the quiet moment by the fire.
What it tastes like:
- Toasted pecan warmth
- Natural honey sweetness
- Buttery, confection-like finish
- Smooth and well-rounded
Who it's for: ✅ Fall coffee drinkers who find straight pumpkin too sweet ✅ People who love nutty, honey-forward flavors ✅ Milk-drink enthusiasts (this makes an exceptional latte) ✅ Gift buyers (the sophisticated flavor profile pleases most palates)
How to brew it:
- Latte base: Shines beautifully in milk drinks - the honey and pecan notes carry through
- Pour-over: Brings out the subtle complexity
- Drip coffee: Everyday warming cup that pairs with everything
Pairs with: Pecan pie, pumpkin bread, cinnamon rolls, apple crisp, roasted sweet potato dishes
🍵 Pumpkin and Cream Rooibos Tea - $9.95 (3 oz)
The afternoon alternative. Rooibos is naturally caffeine-free, which makes this tea perfect for afternoons when you want the warmth and ritual without the extra caffeine kick.
What it tastes like:
- Nuanced, creamy warmth
- Natural pumpkin character
- Smooth rooibos earthiness
- Comforting dessert-adjacent finish
Who it's for: ✅ Afternoon tea drinkers ✅ People sensitive to caffeine ✅ Pregnant or nursing drinkers who miss their PSL ✅ Bedtime wind-down ritual seekers ✅ Guests who don't drink coffee
How to brew it:
- Standard prep: 1 tsp per 8oz hot water, steep 5-7 minutes
- Pumpkin tea latte: Steep strong, add steamed milk and maple syrup
- Iced version: Steep concentrated, pour over ice with milk
Pairs with: Pumpkin bread, oatmeal cookies, apple butter toast, cheese boards
Shop Pumpkin and Cream Rooibos Tea →
🫙 Marshmallow Pumpkin Fruit Tea - $9.95 (3 oz)
The dessert tea. Marshmallow Pumpkin leans fully into the dessert direction - it's the tea you brew when you want something that feels like a treat.
What it tastes like:
- Sweet marshmallow comfort
- Warm pumpkin spice
- Fruit tea base
- Naturally caffeine-free
Who it's for: ✅ Dessert tea lovers ✅ Evening treat seekers ✅ Kids and families (naturally caffeine-free) ✅ Movie night companions ✅ Fall mocktail enthusiasts (makes an incredible base)
How to brew it:
- Standard prep: 1 tbsp per 8oz hot water, steep 5-7 minutes
- Dessert version: Steep strong, top with whipped cream and cinnamon
- Mocktail base: Cold-brew overnight, mix with apple cider for a fall drink
Pairs with: Marshmallow s'mores, pumpkin pie, vanilla ice cream, graham crackers
Shop Marshmallow Pumpkin Fruit Tea →
🍎 Cranberry Apple Fruit Tea - $9.95 (3 oz)
The classic autumn warmer. Cranberry Apple is the tea that works for everyone - tart, bright, warming, and classic without being over-the-top sweet.
What it tastes like:
- Rich cranberry tartness
- Crisp apple warmth
- Balanced, versatile finish
- Naturally caffeine-free
Who it's for: ✅ Fall purists who prefer classic flavors over trendy ones ✅ Hosts (universally pleasing for guests) ✅ Thanksgiving table drinkers ✅ Hot cider lovers ✅ Anyone wanting a less-sweet fall tea
How to brew it:
- Standard prep: 1 tbsp per 8oz hot water, steep 5-7 minutes
- Mulled version: Add orange peel, cinnamon stick, and clove while steeping
- Fall sangria base: Cold-brew, mix with white wine and sliced apples
- Thanksgiving welcome drink: Serve warm with a cinnamon stick stirrer
Pairs with: Turkey dinner, apple pie, baked brie, cranberry sauce (naturally), cheese boards
Shop Cranberry Apple Fruit Tea →
How to Build Your Perfect Fall Coffee Bar
The five Fall Favorites work beautifully together. Here are the combinations we recommend:
🏡 The Essentials Setup Pumpkin Pie Coffee + Pumpkin and Cream Rooibos Tea Morning coffee + caffeine-free afternoon option. The two most popular picks in one simple setup.
👥 The Hosting Setup Fireside Glow Coffee + Cranberry Apple Fruit Tea + Pumpkin Pie Coffee Covers every guest — coffee drinkers, tea drinkers, and those who want something indulgent. Perfect for Thanksgiving or holiday hosting.
🎁 The Complete Collection All 5 products The ultimate fall coffee bar. Perfect for serious fall enthusiasts, gift giving, or stocking up for the whole season.
💰 The budget stretch: With free shipping on orders over $35, pairing any 2 coffees ($32.04 each with the discount) or 1 coffee + 1 tea gets you free shipping with the two together.
Why This Collection vs. Grocery Store Fall Coffee
A quick honest comparison:
| Factor | Grocery Store Fall Coffee | Latitude 23.5 Fall Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Ingredients | Artificial flavoring | Real spices roasted into beans |
| Freshness | Months old on shelves | Fresh-roasted in Sarasota |
| Specialty grade | Commodity coffee | 100% Specialty Grade Arabica |
| Sourcing | Opaque supply chain | Farm-direct sourcing |
| Flavor | Hollow, syrupy, artificial | Depth, warmth, real character |
The flavor difference is real and immediate. Taste tests consistently prove that specialty coffee with real spices outperforms grocery-store flavored coffee at every price point.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's included in the Fall Favorites Collection?
The Fall Favorites Collection includes two coffees (Pumpkin Pie Coffee and Fireside Glow Coffee at $32.04 each with 10% off) and three teas (Pumpkin and Cream Rooibos Tea, Marshmallow Pumpkin Fruit Tea, and Cranberry Apple Fruit Tea at $9.95 each for 3 oz).
When does the 10% off promotion end?
The 10% off promotion applies to select fall coffees in the Fall Favorites Collection. Check the collection page for the most current promotional details. Free shipping is also available on orders over $35.
Which fall coffee is best for beginners?
Pumpkin Pie Coffee is the most approachable - it's instantly recognizable in flavor and works with any brewing method. Fireside Glow is slightly more sophisticated for those who find straight pumpkin too sweet.
Can I use Pumpkin Pie Coffee to make a pumpkin spice latte?
Yes, and it's genuinely one of the fastest ways to make a great PSL. Brew it strong, steam milk with a splash of maple syrup, pour together. Full recipe details in our complete PSL guide.
Are the fall teas caffeinated?
All three fall teas (Pumpkin and Cream Rooibos, Marshmallow Pumpkin, and Cranberry Apple) are naturally caffeine-free - perfect for afternoons, evenings, kids, or caffeine-sensitive drinkers.
Which fall coffee is best for lattes?
Fireside Glow is exceptional in lattes - the honey and pecan notes carry beautifully through milk. Pumpkin Pie Coffee also makes an excellent latte base, especially for homemade pumpkin spice lattes.
Do these make good gifts?
Yes, the Fall Favorites Collection is one of our most popular gift lineups. The curated nature makes it easy to put together a thoughtful seasonal gift, and the price points work for budgets from $9.95 (a single tea) to $70+ (full coffee gift set).
How should I store fall coffee for best freshness?
Store beans in an airtight container at room temperature, away from light and heat. Avoid refrigerating or freezing coffee - moisture degrades flavor. Grind only what you need for each brew for maximum freshness.
This Fall, Drink Like It Matters
The Fall Favorites Collection isn't just seasonal marketing. It's genuinely a lineup of coffees and teas designed for exactly this moment in the year - when mornings turn crisp, afternoons slow down, and we all want something warming in our cups.
Whether you want a quick PSL shortcut (Pumpkin Pie Coffee), a sophisticated latte base (Fireside Glow), a caffeine-free afternoon ritual (Pumpkin and Cream Rooibos), a dessert treat (Marshmallow Pumpkin), or a classic autumn warmer (Cranberry Apple) - there's a product in this collection that fits your fall perfectly.
And right now, with 10% off select fall coffees + free shipping over $35, there's a real reason to try something new.
Shop the Fall Favorites Collection →
Fresh-roasted in Sarasota. Made for the season. 10% off while fall lasts.
0 comments